An Island Far from Home by John Donahue

An Island Far from HomeReading level: 5.5
Lexile: 690
Genre: Historical fiction
ELL-Friendly: No
Library recommendation: Middle school

Goodreads summary:

The twelve-year-old son of a Union army doctor killed during the fighting in Fredericksburg comes to understand the meaning of war and the fine line between friends and enemies when he begins corresponding with a young Confederate prisoner of war.

Sometimes I bring home really boring-looking YA books that are in the “free” pile at the library. It’s sort of like picking up a hitchhiker: it could be a very bad idea, but you also feel bad for the person and decide to give him/her a ride and do a good deed. Basically, adopting one of these books is a bargain. This one was a “meh” bargain in that it wasn’t terrible but kids probably won’t read it.

An Island Far from Home has a genuinely interesting premise: a kid communicates with an “enemy” kid on the other side of the war. The overall message is that we are all human and that war hurts everyone. It’s also just a sweet story of friendship. Unfortunately, it’s not very well-written and it’s not terribly engaging. It’s more suited for upper elementary and lower middle school. It’s also not very ELL-friendly with outdated vocabulary (from the Civil War) and regional dialects with strong accents.

A book talk could get students interested even if the book itself is a bit of a letdown. I’d begin by saying: imagine that the US is in the middle of a war with Canada (or another country), and a Canadian killed one of your family members. You have the opportunity to write a letter to a kid your age who is an enemy prisoner. Would you write that letter? Is it possible for you and this “enemy” to be friends?

All that said, I won’t get rid of this book just yet. It’s a solid addition to the historical fiction shelf if I wind up teaching middle school. It could be highlighted when learning about the civil war or when a reading challenge is about reading books with dorky covers.

An Island Far from Home is my twenty-sixth book of the 2014 TBR Pile Reading Challenge hosted by Bookish.